Emma Stone has had a series of both high—and low—profile lovers over the years, ever since she hit it big in 2007 when she was cast as Jonah Hill’s love interest in Superbad. The in-demand Hollywood starlet has had numerous relationships, some that have lasted longer than others. Like other Hollywood actresses who’ve garnered massive success in the entertainment industry and under the public eye, Emma Stone’s boyfriends list has grown extensively over the past few years.
And that’s not to say she hasn’t enjoyed her fair share of steamy onscreen romances with the likes of Hollywood’s hunkiest leading men! Do those romantic Ryan Gosling scenes ring a bell? (Drool!)
Their chemistry was nothing short of palpable in movies like Crazy Stupid Love (2011), Gangster Squad (2013), and La La Land (2016). But were they ever actually “a thing?”
For the longest time, her public on-again, off again long-term relationship with The Amazing Spider-Man (2012) costar, Andrew Garfield managed to fuel supermarket tabloid banter, and fans around the world were loving them.
But, it seems like that spark has fizzled out for good since their 2015 amicable breakup. Still, they both speak highly of each other in public forums.
So, who is Emma Stone dating now and who has she dated in the past?
Keep reading our Emma Stone dating timeline to find out all of the juicy details!
Teddy Geiger (Pre-transition)
Dating Timeline: 2007–2009
Years ago, Emma Stone dated singer, songwriter, musician, and producer Teddy Geiger. When they started dating, Geiger was already a very big name in the music industry.
Many people have probably forgotten they were once an item, but the Internet never forgets. Photographic evidence of their relationship still lingers in the dark abyss of cyberspace, where it’ll stay forever.
The reason their breakup was not revealed at the time.
Since then, Geiger has continued to enjoy a very successful music career. He has even worked on several projects with musical sensation and close friend, Shawn Mendes.
Then, in October of last year, Geiger revealed to fans in a prolific Instagram post that he is transgender and was in the process of transitioning from male to female. The announcement was well-received by Geiger’s countless fans, and since then, Geiger got the courage to appear on her first red carpet as a woman!
Dating Timeline: 2009–2011
Among other things, you may recognize Kieran Culkin as Kevin McCallister’s adorable and mischievous bed-wetting younger cousin, Fuller, in Home Alone. At the time, a lot of people probably didn’t realize that Kieran and Macaulay Culkin were actually brothers in real life!
In 2009, the 35-year-old actor starred alongside Emma Stone in the independent comedy-drama that he cowrote with Michele Mulroney entitled Paper Man. Shortly after that, he and Stone started dating.
Their relationship would go on to last about two years until she started filming The Amazing Spider-Man, and the rest, as they say, is history. That’s pretty much around the time when Stone and Culkin called it quits, and she started dating Andrew Garfield.
Since then, Culkin has been able to revive his career and has worked on many film and television projects. He married his wife, Jazz Charton, in 2013.
Dating Timeline: 2010–2015
Everyone has that one ex that seems to be the one that got away; the one that you always seem to go back to, for one reason or another. And for Emma Stone, it seems Andrew Garfield was that person.
The pair started dating while they were filming The Amazing Spider-Man. For several years after that, they were on-and-off, always giving fans a brief glimmer of hope that the next time they got back together would be permanent.
Some people even speculated that they were well on their way to getting engaged. But sadly, those rumors never came true.
Instead, they went on to have what could arguably be referred to as one of the most amicable breakups in Hollywood history! Despite having ended their relationship—much to the dismay of all of their fans—the pair always speaks fondly of one another. They seem to have maintained a very strong friendship, even today.
Recently, on May 22, 2018, Garfield and Stone were allegedly spotted having dinner together at a restaurant in New York City. Many people thought this dinner was indicative that the “pals” were rekindling their former romance. But this doesn’t seem to be the case, as it appears another man seems to have stolen Stone’s heart!
Dating Timeline: 2017–2018
Stone and McCary first met on the set of SNL when he directed the episode that she hosted on December 3, 2017. The two have reportedly been dating since then.
McCary apparently has a very low-key personality and prefers to work behind the scenes rather than being the center of attention. This is why he likes directing segments on the long-running sketch comedy show.
It’s unknown whether they’re still together, as their last known public sighting was on February 5 of this year. Since then, Emma has also been spotted with Jennifer Anniston’s ex-husband, Justin Theroux, which has sparked rumors that they’re now an item!
Dating Timeline: N/A
The two actors are currently starring in a Netflix show called Maniac together. They were seen enjoying a late-night sushi dinner earlier this month, presumably after a full day of shooting.
Pictures have surfaced of the two of them walking down the street and laughing together, leaving many people wondering whether they’re dating.
Other celebrity gossip sites have also reported that Theroux and Stone vacationed together in the South of France and were seen canoodling among a group of friends. The pair has also appeared at several other high-profile events together, such as a Louis Vuitton Fashion Show.
When asked to confirm whether Stone and Theroux are an exclusive couple, their close mutual friend, Jonathan Van Ness (one of the stars of the Queer Eye revival on Netflix), vehemently denied those rumors,
Van Ness stated, “They’re friends. We’re all friends. Men and women can be friends and it can just be friendly.”
So, there you have it, folks. Straight from the horse’s mouth! Emma Stone and Justin Theroux are decidedly not dating. But that doesn’t mean there isn’t any hope for the future!
Just like any celebrity, Emma Stone’s dating history is still being written, so anything’s possible!